What if the marketing agency you hired to grow your business is actually holding you back?
A lot of businesses turn to agencies to hit their marketing goals, trusting their expertise to deliver results. But the truth is, not all agencies have your best interests in mind. Some care more about their own profits than your success, covering up poor performance with confusing metrics or misleading jargon.
If you’re not careful, you could end up overpaying for disappointing results—and worse, losing trust in future partnerships. Here are some red flags to look out for.
Transparency is key to a strong client-agency relationship, but let’s face it—some agencies hide behind technical jargon or cherry-picked stats to make themselves look good, even when they’re not delivering real results.
If your agency is reporting “vanity metrics” like impressions, clicks, or reach without tying them to actual business outcomes (like leads or revenue), it’s time to pay attention. For example, a campaign might get lots of clicks but barely any conversions. If conversions are your main goal, then what’s the point of all those clicks?
Red flag: If you ask for clear performance insights and they dodge the question or drown you in useless data, they’re probably not focused on what really matters.
The fix? Ask for metrics that impact your bottom line, like cost per conversion rates or return on ad spend (ROAS). A great marketing partner will break these numbers down in a way that’s easy to understand.
“We’ll 10x your revenue in 3 months!” Sound familiar? If it does, it’s probably time to pump the brakes. Promises like this often sound too good to be true—because they usually are.
No legit agency can guarantee results without first diving into your business, data, target audience, and competition. Overpromising is just a way to reel clients in, but it almost always leads to disappointment. In fact, a study by Ernst & Young found that 57% of business leaders were let down by an agency’s performance within the first year.
Red Flag: They overhype their skills or promise unrealistically quick results.
Solution: Find an agency that takes the time to truly understand your business before making any claims. Ask them specific questions about their strategy and past results before signing on.
Your business is one of a kind, and your marketing strategy should show it. If your agency is pushing cookie-cutter campaigns without taking the time to understand your goals, they’re missing the mark.
Take Google Ads or Facebook Campaigns, for example—if that’s all they’re suggesting without exploring other channels, it may show a lack of creativity or understanding of your audience. The best marketing strategies are tailored, multi-channel, and built to tackle your unique challenges while focusing on connecting with your ideal customers.
Red Flag: Their proposed strategy looks exactly like what they’ve done for other clients, with little effort to customize it for you.
Solution: Choose a partner who incorporates strategy into their client projects—whether it’s designing a website, managing social media, running digital ad campaigns, or developing a comprehensive marketing campaign.
Your agency should feel like part of your team, not some distant contractor you’re constantly chasing for updates. If they’re not keeping you in the loop or communicating regularly about your campaign, it might be a sign they’re lazy or have set it and forget it.
Forbes points out that good agencies keep clients in the know with useful updates—not just when things are going smoothly, but especially when there are challenges.
Red Flag: They don’t provide regular updates or address your concerns quickly.
Solution: Set clear expectations upfront for regular check-ins and open conversations. That way, you can stay in control without needing to micromanage.
One of the most common ways agencies take advantage of businesses is by owning your key digital assets. They might control your website, hosting, Google Analytics, or ad accounts, leaving you with little access or even risking losing it all if you decide to part ways.
For example, if the agency built your website and hosts it on their servers, you could face major disruptions or extra fees to regain control if you try to leave.
Red Flag: They lock you out of crucial accounts or refuse to grant full access to your website, analytics, or ad platforms.
Solution: Make sure you own your assets from the start. Use your accounts for hosting, analytics, and ads to ensure you retain full control, even if you decide to change agencies.
If you’ve noticed any of these red flags, it’s worth asking yourself whether your marketing agency is truly your partner or just another vendor. Marketing should drive results, not confusion or frustration.
We’re not an agency—we’re your marketing partner. We focus on empowering businesses with marketing strategies, expertise, and insights that prioritize your growth, not ours. If you’re looking for a second opinion or a better marketing partner, we’re here.
"*" indicates required fields
